Blue-skying Brands; Plus, Summize Delivers Sensical UGC to Twitter

Traditionally advertisers’ job has been to talk about a promise of expected utility about their, or their clients’, goods and services. To do that, they’ve paid producers of content to attract readers, listeners, and viewers and get them to engage with advertising.

But now—for a whole mess of really interesting economic and social reasons, like cheap interaction and expensive attention—people think that listening is becoming more important that projecting. Advertisers, or their clients, are supposed to listen to their consumers, who in markets, networks, and communities , are collectively generating UGC, or “user generated context”—”the result of the complex, multilevel network effects that hapen when millions of consumers connect.”

Can content producers “seed” the conversational context to which advertisers are supposed to listen?

Consider a restaurant that once would have stuck slick ads in fancy magazines. Now the restaurant might pay a blogger to review the magazine and attract a lively customer-driven conversation comprising replies to the post and comments on it.

But wait! Doesn’t that represent a hopeless conflict of interest? Isn’t that just payola? Well, not if the restaurant is actually interested in listening—because they want to form their strategy around their customers’ beliefs. If they were engaging in payola, on the contrary, they would be trying to form their customers’ beliefs around their strategy. That’s projecting, or talking.

The idea is that restaurant welcomes a bitter review for the opportunity to draw out customer agreement (in which case it can learn what to change or improve) or, hopefully, provoke customer rebuke (in which case it can focus on new improvements).

Note that the money still flows from an advertiser (or its client, like a restaurant) to a producer of content. Content still flows from producers to consumers. This hasn’t changed.

But the thing that contains the “beliefs” about the brand used to flow from the advertiser to the consumer (via an ad); flowing in the opposite direction was engagement from consumer to advertiser. Now the thing that contains the beliefs about the brans flows from the consumer to the advertiser (via UGC); flowing in the opposite direction is now engagement from advertiser to consumer. This has reversed.

PS. This is more or less how you monetize twitter+summize.

Leave a Reply




Josh Young's Facebook profile

What I’m thinking

What I'm saving.

RSS What I’m reading.

  • FriendFeed Sneaks Into My RSS Stats And Hits The Big Red Button 2009 June 18
    It's tempting to go back the age-old line of there being lies, damn lies, and statistics. On the Web, where practically everything is measured and big numbers are almost always better, counting up one's followers, friends, subscribers or authority is practically a pasttime. But with each metric comes a question of validity - how did they approach t […]
    louisgray@gmail.com (Louis Gray)
  • Introducing our new venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz 2009 July 6
    My partner Ben Horowitz and I are delighted to announce the formation of our new venture capital firm, Andreessen Horowitz, and our first fund -- $300 million in size -- aimed purely at investing in the best new entrepreneurs, products, and companies in the technology industry. Between the two of us, Ben and I have started three companies directly, created […]
    Marc Andreessen
  • Controlling Data Through URL Shorteners 2009 June 30
    I’m going to sidestep the “URL shorteners are bad because they obfuscate” discussion in this post. If you’re reading this, you likely have an opinion one way or another on that topic, but let’s leave that at the door. A bigger challenge is emerging as URL shortening continues to proliferate. Web browsers unwinding a shortened URL when a user clicks on one is […]
    Jud Valeski
  • Semantic Technology Conference kicks off with Keynotes from Open Calais and Siri 2009 June 16
    June 16th, 2009 Semantic Technology Conference kicks off with Keynotes from Open Calais and Siri Posted by Paul Miller @ 9:54 am Categories: Commercialisation, Open Data, Semantic Web, Semantic Web Companies, Web 2.0, Web 3.0 Tags: Web, Advertisement, Tool, Siri, Tom Tague, Tague, Enterprise Adoption, Virtual Personal Assistant, Virtual Persona […]
    (author unknown)
  • How to Tell Stories in Print 2009 July 2
    Over at The Atlantic, I’ve been interviewing Jack Hitt, one of my favorite journalists. If you’ve never heard the This American Life episode The Super, do yourself the favor of consuming it immediately. It’s just damn good storytelling. The same can be said for Jack’s magazine stories. One example is Toxic Dreams, one of the most impressive magazine stories […]
    Conor Friedersdorf
  • Beyond celebrity obsession 2009 June 27
    Great minds discuss ideas. Average minds discuss events. Small minds discuss people. — Eleanor Roosevelt Somebody I wish to discuss an idea here. It’s an idea about celebrity, and it follows an event that has become a black hole in nearly all media: the death of Michael Jackson. According to Don Norman, a black hole topic is one that is essentially undiscus […]
    Doc Searls
  • Beyond celebrity obsession 2009 July 1
    Shared by joshyoung "Great minds discuss ideas. Average minds discuss events. Small minds discuss people." So very, very false! We all discuss all of the above—and places too. Great minds discuss ideas. Average minds discuss events. Small minds discuss people. — Eleanor Roosevelt Somebody I wish to discuss an idea here. It’s an idea about celebr […]
    (author unknown)
  • Force-Directed Edge Bundling for Graph Visualization 2009 June 16
    Attentive readers might already know the concept of "edge bundling" as described in a post almost 2 years ago, and more recently exemplified by the Eigenfactor Citation Patterns graph. Edge bundling is based on the principle of visually bundling adjacency edges together, analogous to the way electrical wires and network cables are merged into bund […]
    (author unknown)
  • Real-Time But Not Ready For Prime Time 2009 June 18
    Extra, extra, read all about it–two new real-time search engines debuted today: CrowdEye and Collecta. I love the headlines from Techmeme: Mashable!: Collecta: True Real-Time Social Search paidContent: Startup Promises Best Real-Time Search Results Yet Tech Beat: Collecta Launches *Really* Real-Time Search Engine ReadWriteWeb: Collecta: Summize Backer Launc […]
    Daniel Tunkelang
  • Wikipedia Page Traffic Statistics Dataset 2009 July 1
    Wikipedia Page Traffic Statistics Dataset Posted by Peter Skomoroch on June 11th 2009 to Data mining, Amazon EC2, dataset I’ve published a Wikipedia Page Traffic Data Set containing a 320 GB sample of the data used to power trendingtopics.org (I’ll talk about Trending Topics more in a upcoming post). The EBS s […]
    Peter Skomoroch